Simultaneous Assessment of CAR Expression and Target-Specific Binding on CAR T Cells by Flow Cytometry

CAR T Cell Detection

As Chimeric Antigen Receptor (CAR) T cell therapies advance from discovery through clinical development, analytical methods are increasingly expected to provide meaningful characterization of product identity and function. Flow cytometry is widely used to assess CAR expression on T cells, traditionally relying on surrogate detection reagents such as anti-linker antibodies, anti-tag antibodies, or reporter proteins (e.g., GFP) to monitor CAR-positive cells (1).

The U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has emphasized the importance of direct CAR detection for identity testing of CAR T cell products. In its guidance for industry, the FDA recommends direct detection of the CAR to determine the percentage of CAR-positive cells and advises that when surrogate markers or broad-specificity reagents (e.g., Protein L) are used, their correlation with CAR expression, sensitivity, and specificity should be evaluated and justified (2). Anti-idiotype antibodies have been used successfully for direct CAR detection; however, suitable anti-idiotype reagents are not always available for every CAR target (3). As a result, surrogate detection methods often remain the only practical option during CAR construct screening, selection, and optimization, particularly as CAR designs become increasingly complex, including dual-target CARs, cytokine-engager CARs, and other next-generation formats.

Recombinant bioactive target proteins offer an attractive alternative for direct, antigen-specific CAR T cell detection. For example, a recombinant CD19 dimer can be used to directly detect CAR expression on T cells by flow cytometry while simultaneously confirming target-binding specificity and potency. This approach aligns with the FDA’s emphasis on direct CAR detection by providing a single assay that measures both CAR expression and functional antigen recognition, resulting in a more biologically relevant characterization of CAR T cells throughout research, process development, and quality control testing.

Q&A

Why use recombinant target proteins for antigen-specific CAR T detection?

Recent studies on the development and optimization of the best strategies for CAR T detection have demonstrated that antigen-specific detection outperforms other forms of CAR detection. Universal CAR detection reagents, such as anti-Fab antibodies and Protein L, are hindered by higher background staining than recombinant target proteins. Meanwhile, recombinant target proteins provide a direct, biologically relevant method for detecting CAR T cells by measuring the CAR’s ability to bind its specific antigen. Unlike anti-tag or anti-linker antibodies, antigen-specific detection confirms functional target recognition rather than simply the presence of the CAR on the cell surface. This approach enables more physiologically relevant characterization of CAR T cells during discovery and optimization.

FeatureRecombinant Target ProteinsSurrogate Marker
What is detected?Functional target-binding CARsLinker of scFv, or kVL of scFv, or tag sequence
Measures antigen recognition?YesNo
Reflects biological function?HighLow
Supports early CAR screening workflows?ExcellentGood
Detects non-functional CAR expression?Less likelyPossible

Bottom line: Recombinant target proteins allow researchers to detect CAR T cells based on their ability to bind the specific antigen rather than simply confirming the presence of a CAR construct. This provides a more biologically relevant readout for CAR T screening, optimization, and characterization studies.

References:

  1. Wang SA, et al. Flow cytometry-based monitoring of chimeric antigen receptor (CAR) T cells. Cytometry Part B: Clinical Cytometry. 
  2. U.S. Food and Drug Administration. Considerations for the Development of Chimeric Antigen Receptor (CAR) T Cell Products: Guidance for Industry. Center for Biologics Evaluation and Research; January 2024 
  3. Jayaraman J, Mellody MP, Hou AJ, et al. The Chimeric Antigen Receptor Detection Toolkit. Frontiers in Immunology. 2020;11:177

Related Resources

cd19 cartoon
Product Spotlight

CD19 Proteins

CD19 Proteins CD19 is a type I transmembrane glycoprotein in the immunoglobulin superfamily expressed on B cells throughout development and widely used as a marker

Read More »

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *